如何正确实现多线程安全的singleton patterns

2008-02-23 10:05:12来源:互联网 阅读 ()

新老客户大回馈,云服务器低至5折

Singleton Pattern


Short Introduction

Singleton pattern, described in the GOF Design Patterns book, is one of the most easily understandable and on of the most frequently used pattern. The goal of the singleton pattern is to make sure that there is only one instance of this class in the system and allow other classes Access this instance.

Case study

Today I tried to extend a exist MVC system in our project. Because only one instance of the Controller is needed in the system (typical Singleton pattern), a traditional singleton pattern was implemented here. The code is looked like:

public class Controller {

private static Controller instance;

public Controller()

{

// do something

}



public final static Controller getInstance(){



public final static Controller getInstance(){

(A)

if (instance == null) {

(B)

instance = new Controller();

}

return instance;

}

// some more methods

}

The above shown code is, just like it described in almost all Design patterns books, is beautiful and correct based on the traditional implantation of singleton pattern.

Just at this time, our Team leader came to me, saw the implementation and told me at the first second that the traditional implementation is NOT thread safe! Yes! It is thread unsafe, after I read the code once again. Why? Let us make try: two threads T1 and T2 try to call the class Controller. When T1 goes to the position (B) in the above shown code, it sleeps. Then comes T2 to the position (A) and checks whether an instance of the Controller exists. Because T1 sleeps at the position (B) before an instance will be created, T2 can go into the block and create a new instance of Controller. Now T1 is awake, and what will it do? Just create another instance of Controller, because it is already in the block! So, great! TWO instance are created! It is no more singleton!

The first simple idea that I got in the first second, as you estimated, is adding the key word synchronized before the method getInstance(). But this brings bad Performance. As we knew, the normally used solution for such a problem is to moving the synchronizing into the method. That means to building a synchronized block in the method. The code should be looked like this:

public class Controller {

private static Controller instance;

public Controller()

{

// do something

}

标签:

版权申明:本站文章部分自网络,如有侵权,请联系:west999com@outlook.com
特别注意:本站所有转载文章言论不代表本站观点,本站所提供的摄影照片,插画,设计作品,如需使用,请与原作者联系,版权归原作者所有

上一篇:Servlet与JSP教程

下一篇:《Java编程思想》(第二版)第6:重复运用classes